Moving Beyond Job Creation

Defining and Measuring the Creation of Quality Jobs

Overview

This discussion paper is designed to help Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) define and measure job quality. It defines a quality job as one that contains most (if not all) of five elements: a living wage, basic benefits, career-building opportunities, wealth-building opportunities, and a fair and engaging workplace. The paper offers impact measurement practices to assess and report on job quality to help CDFIs encourage and support their business borrowers to enhance the quality of jobs they offer. While this resource is written for lenders, it has applications for all practitioners seeking to define and measure job quality within a firm.

Related Resources

The Resource Library is the heart of the Job Quality Center of Excellence. Check out our recent additions below, and click “View All Resources” to explore more.
Businesswoman hand placing or pulling wooden block on the tower. Business planning, Risk Management, Solution and strategy Concepts
Report2024
Benefits Beyond Measure
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
The staff prepares the delivery box on the motorcycle for delivery to customers.
Report2024
“Just Make It Better.” What Gig Workers Have to Say About Gig Work
The Workers Lab
Two Male University Students Building Machine In Science Robotics Or Engineering Class
Report2024
Issue Brief
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Smiling female client talking to male manager
Report2024
Issue Brief
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Young woman and man laughing in commercial kitchen
Report2024
The Potential of Guaranteed Income to Empower Workers and Improve Job Quality
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
doctor discussing prescription
Report2024
The Complete Guide to Supporting Employee Mental Health
WorkLife Partnership
Industrial technology concept.
Report2024
Does employee ownership improve performance
Rutgers University, et al.
Portable Benefits in Action
Report2024
Portable Benefits in Action
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
florists with digital tablet in flower shop
Report2024
Insights from Businesses
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Tax preparation
Report2024
The Original Portable Benefit
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Warehouse employees using laptop in plant
Report2024
Promoting Equity and Inclusion and Connection to Good Fit Jobs for Young Adults
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Screenshot
Report2024
Exploring Portable Worker Training
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Startup successful small business owner man walking in his coffee shop or restaurant.
Report2024
To Build Back Better, Job Quality Is the Key
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Money management tips
Report2024
Race and Gender Wealth Equity and the Role of Employee Share Ownership
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Carpenter Training Female Apprentice To Use Plane
Report2024
Unpacking the Work of Work-Based Learning
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
From Ideal Worker To Ideal Workplace
Report2024
From Ideal Worker To Ideal Workplace
ideas42 and Time's Up Foundation
Voices from the Field
Report2024
Voices from the Field
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
A grocery’s cashier checking out products.
Report2024
An Equity Imperative
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Smiling African waitress using a restaurant point of sale terminal
Report2024
Roadmap to Reimagine Restaurants
One Fair Wage, et al.
Female student back at school and wearing a facemask during the pandemic
Report2024
Policies to Support Workers During Coronavirus
National Partnership for Women and Families, et al.
African American civil engineer and worker wearing face masks while elbow bumping at construction site.
Report2024
Employee Ownership
ICA Group
Female African American civil engineer with protective face mask at construction site.
Report2024
Let’s Take Action
PolicyLink
Embracing Open-Book Management
Report2024
Embracing Open-Book Management to Fuel Employee Engagement and Corporate Sustainability
UNC Kenan-Flagler Business School
Black Women’s History Labor
Report2024
Analysis of Black Women’s Historical Labor Trends & Systemic Barriers to Economic Mobility
Women's Fund of the Greater Cincinnati Foundation
Builder And Female Apprentice Carrying Wood On Site
Report2024
Job Quality Learnings Report
National Fund for Workforce Solutions
Understanding Good Jobs
Report2024
Understanding Good Jobs
Urban Institute
A grocery’s cashier checking out products.
Report2024
How COVID-19 Affected the Quality of Work
Gallup
Hispanic woman working at a dry cleaner
Report2024
Advancing Frontline Workers of Color
FSG and PolicyLink
Multi-ethnic workers in warehouse having meeting
Report2024
Awake to Woke to Work
Equity in the Center
The Catapult Papers Essay
Report2024
The Catapult Papers Essay #3
Jewish Vocational Services
The Roadmap for Racial Equity
Report2024
The Roadmap for Racial Equity
National Skills Coalition
Ambitious african black female employee speaking at diverse meeting
Report2024
Workers’ Rights for Workforce Development
University of Illinois Labor Education Program
Effects of Manufacturing Extensions
Report2024
Genesis at Work
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Worker In Warehouse Preparing Goods For Dispatch
Report2024
Not Just a Job
Gallup
Advancing Frontline Women in Retail
Report2024
Advancing Frontline Women in Retail
FSG
As you can see, we follow this working plan here!
Report2024
Exploring Employee Share Ownership as a Potential Investment Strategy in Opportunity Zones
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Female warehouse worker stacking boxes onto the rack
Report2024
The Practice of Improving Job Quality
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Reconnecting Work and Wealth
Report2024
Reconnecting Work and Wealth
The Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Concerned business woman
Report2024
2019 Guidebook
Chicago Beyond
Lecturer Helps Scholar with Project, Advising on Their Work. Teacher Giving Lesson to Diverse Multiethnic Group of Female and Male Students in College Room, Teaching New Academic Skills on a Computer.
Report2024
Making Work-Based Learning Work for Retail
JFF Center for Apprenticeship & Work-Based Learning
Partnering for Equity
Report2024
Partnering for Equity
The University of Texas at Austin – Ray Marshall Center for the Study of Human Resources
Stable Scheduling Study
Report2024
Stable Scheduling Study
Center for WorkLife Law
Investing in Workforce Program Innovation
Report2024
Investing in Workforce Program Innovation
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
People profile heads. Vector background pattern.
Report2024
The Competitive Advantage of Racial Equity
FSG and PolicyLink
LGBTQ Nonprofit Staff
Report2024
Working at the Intersections
Building Movement Project
Philanthropy and the Future of Work
Report2024
Philanthropy and the Future of Work
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Restore the Promise of Work
Report2024
Restore the Promise of Work
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Apprenticeship
Report2024
Apprenticeship
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Portrait Of Smiling Male And Female College Students With Teachers Outside School Building
Report2024
Connecting Young Adults To Employment
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program
Close-up image of a businesswoman working on the computer.
Report2024
Moving Beyond Job Creation
Pacific Community Ventures
Banner template Partner Business Trust Teamwork Partnership. Industry contractor fist bump dealing mission business. Mission team meeting group of People Fist bump Hands together. Business Concept
Report2024
Next Generation Employer-Engagement Strategies
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Apprenticeship
Report2024
Apprenticeship
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program, et al.
Construction law
Report2024
Your Rights at Work
AFL-CIO
Men shaking hands in an industrial facility
Report2024
Selling Your Business to Your Employees
Democracy at Work Institute, et al.
Sectoral Strategies
Report2024
Sectoral Strategies for Low-Income Workers
Aspen Institute Economic Opportunities Program

Submit a Resource

What resources have you found useful for advancing job quality? Share your favorites so we can consider adding them to the Job Quality Center of Excellence.

Submit A Resource